Catcher and pitcher communication and paranoia, a breakdown
What Happened
In this 2019 breakdown, Jomboy zooms in on the silent chess match between Gary Sanchez and Masahiro Tanaka during a Yankees game against the Astros. The focus is on paranoia: Sanchez runs multiple-sign sequences even with the bases empty, sets up in his target location at the last possible second, and fakes glove placement (showing high, then dropping low) to keep anyone watching from tipping the hitter. Jomboy also points out the relationship stuff, like Sanchez waving off the umpire after taking a foul ball off the thigh so he doesn't break Tanaka's rhythm, and Sanchez flashing three fingers and pointing at the wristband to change the sign sequence mid at-bat against George Springer and Jose Altuve.
Why This Matters
This video aged into something bigger than its runtime. Published in October 2019, it spotlights catcher-pitcher paranoia about sign-stealing right before the Astros banging scheme blew up that November and led to MLB suspensions and the firings of A.J. Hinch and Jeff Luhnow. Watching a Yankees battery obsess over disguising signs against Houston in the ALCS hits different once you know what was actually happening in that organization. The mechanics Jomboy explains are real baseball craft: multiple-sign sequences to beat a runner peeking from second, late glove setup, and decoy targets. Wristband sign changes mid at-bat became standard practice across the league in the seasons after, partly because of the trust issues this era created. The little rhythm details, like quick return throws and waving off timeout, are the unglamorous stuff that separates good game-callers from great ones.
With 2.4M views, this breakdown ranks #81 of 1,583 Jomboy videos, landing in the top 5% of the entire catalog.
Key Moments
Who / What Is Involved
Players: Gary Sanchez, Masahiro Tanaka. Teams: Yankees.
Key Terms Mentioned
Full Transcript
Click timestamps to jump to that momentI wanted to talk about catcher and
pitcher relationships and how paranoid
everyone is look at this no one is on
base and Gary is giving Tanaka a
sequence of signs there's no one on
usually when there's a runner on second
you think he's peeking in and trying to
tell the hitter what's coming so you do
a sequence I also like that let me go
back a little bit
Gary flicks the thumb up which usually
means the high pitch is coming if
anyone's watching it doesn't this is a
low pitch
so they got a sequence going with no one
on Gary's doing whatever he can to trick
them and it's just the whole game these
little things are going on I love the
communication between the pitcher and
the catcher look how late Gary's setting
up in his location because he doesn't
want anyone signaling to the batter
outside inside high down so he's just
waiting a lot of pitchers might want to
see the glove so they know where they're
aiming can't risk it everyone's paranoid
look how late he sets up into the spot
he wants to be to not get yelling at
himself they're mad and then he's doing
when they want it high they want him to
chase that pitch or just see it so he's
setting up hide let him know he doesn't
care if they know but other times he
fakes the glove high and then goes low
does this work I don't know probably not
but they do it just in case people are
looking at where he sets up if they're
cheating if someone's relaying another
thing is getting the ball back to the
pitcher fast in a rhythm and this isn't
special to Gary Sanchez where Moss
here's naka this every catcher does this
it's just cool I like it so look how
fast he gets it back you want to keep
the pitcher in a good rhythm and keep
them going especially when they're
feeling good even when you take a foul
ball to the thigh and the umpires trying
to call timeout to see if you're okay
you say no no no no no blue I'm keeping
massa and his rhythm Lucas took this
ball right to the thigh the umpire and
the catcher usually I have an agreement
like we'll call timeout for each other
if we get banged up he doesn't and then
look at this I like the positive
Reformation the catcher gives the
pitcher like I that was close I know we
should have had it I thought it was good
nice pitch a lot of communication goes
on without saying any words haha yeah I
thought wouldn't look good to gets out
of the inning here with the pop-up and
Gary's happy form and clapping the glove
I like watching that little stuff
and this is a cool at-bat so takes the
splitter there Gary goes up gets there's
a called strike nods his head so he
fakes high they go low and Gary nods his
head like no even though he didn't chase
but that's a good pitch but Gary says
well he spat on that so let's change the
sequence so he tells Tanaka they're
changing the sequence
Tanaka looks in his hat and he's like
okay I got the new sequence we're good
to go
fakes high again goes low gets the K now
here's another at-bat where stuff like
this happens Altuve is up and he's gonna
chase that pitch and then he's not
chasing the slider right there I mean it
was pretty bad pitch way off the zone he
doesn't chase that splitter just looks
at it and then he's got a doesn't chase
that one the next one he's got a big
swing and we're kind of getting deep in
the count four pitches have been thrown
that's the fifth pitch and you can see
Gary he holds up the three fingers top
left and then points to the wristband
tells Tanaka we're changing the sequence
we've thrown five pitches he took a big
hack at that one let's change it up
maybe they're on to something big swing
again and then he's gonna get him
swinging and that ends the inning and
then that ends the video