Umpire messed up the same call all game, a breakdown
What Happened
In a heated exchange between the Baltimore Orioles and the New York Mets, tensions boil over as the Orioles' manager, Brandon Hyde, vehemently argues with the home plate umpire, Tim Timmons. The disagreement stems from Timmons' perceived inconsistency in calling low strikes throughout the game, with the Orioles' dugout growing increasingly frustrated. Brandon Hyde, the fiery Orioles skipper, steps out of the dugout to confront Timmons, gesturing emphatically and staring him down. The umpire stands his ground, but Hyde's frustration is palpable as he questions Timmons' strike zone. The exchange grows more heated, with both men raising their voices and Hyde appearing to take exception to Timmons' non-verbal cues. As the argument escalates, Mets manager Buck Showalter also makes his way out of the dugout to intervene, attempting to calm the situation. The three men engage in a tense discussion, with Timmons maintaining his stance while Hyde and Showalter express their grievances. The players from both teams observe the heated exchange, their attention diverted from the game at hand. At the heart of the dispute is Timmons' perceived inconsistency in calling low strikes, a trend that the Orioles' dugout has been voicing their displeasure about throughout the game. "We're good, I told him it was inside," says one of the Orioles players, capturing the essence of their frustration. provided by the video's host, , delves deeper into the technical aspects of pitch framing and how the different catching techniques employed by the Mets and Orioles catchers may have contributed to Timmons' inconsistent strike calls. Alvarez, the Orioles' catcher, is shown to have a more effective technique for presenting the low pitches to the umpire, leading to a higher rate of strikes being called, while the Mets' catcher, Adley Rutschman, struggles to get the same calls. The video's analysis highlights the nuances of pitch framing and the impact it can have on an umpire's decision-making process. 's insights provide a deeper understanding of the technical aspects of the game and the strategies employed by teams to gain a competitive edge. As the confrontation between the managers and the umpire continues, the players from both teams remain engaged, eager to see the outcome of the heated exchange. The intensity of the moment underscores the high stakes and the emotions that can flare up during a closely contested game between two rival teams.
Full Transcript
Click timestamps to jump to that momentwhat are you pointing at me for we're
good I told him it was
inside okay re
relax what are you pointing at me for
then you piece of oh my goodness
this breakdown is brought to you by seek
thank you very much to seek for
sponsoring this breakdown Bern's upset
the umps upset they're going back and
forth it's getting heated he's staring
at whoa dude that is the opposite of
relaxing I haven't been yelling at you
okay so what the you pointing for
relax just stop oh my goodness now the
manager's got to come out now this face
that he's making is actually the face
the Orioles dugouts been making at his
calls all game and they've been chirping
him I guess it wasn't burnsy though and
this is the source of the frustration on
low pitches there you have it Baltimore
all balls there's one strike but that
one's in the corner but anything low all
balls okay and you say well yeah but
look Jimmy those are below the Zone he's
calling those correctly well here's what
the other team the Mets low pitches look
like all
strikes so the Orioles are upset I did a
video on my show Jimmy's three things on
the talking Baseball channel I do more
deep Dives more technical breakdowns
into stuff that I find really
interesting I love catchers techniques
so here's a breakdown of how these two
Graphics came to be how the low strike
got called two completely different ways
here's a big difference Alvarez is off
to the side letting tempay see he sees
the whole Lane nothing's in his way
where you
got uh adley is kind of blocking him a
little bit adley is holding the target
up the whole time so adley's glove
starts up right Alvarez's glove starts
down and that means that Alvarez is
letting the Umpire see the ball the
entire time on the left because his
glove just comes up and then comes up
quickly even more and then he drops the
ball meanwhile on the right what adley's
doing is his glove goes up and then he's
gonna his glove goes down so if the
Umpire sees him means he might not have
hit his spot well the new catching style
I've made videos on this before is don't
let him see where you're intending to
throw it so the Umpire doesn't have any
preconceived notions and what Ally does
is he holds the glove there for a long
time jerks it up holds it there to try
and get the call Alvarez doesn't do that
he just flashes it up real quick okay
still not convinced that that's that
much of a difference to be making such a
difference in the way the Umpire calls
it well here is overlay of the side view
and look how much further up Alvarez is
than adley rushman he's setting up so
much
closer and the pitch is coming and now
they both reach their gloves
out and now look at their glove
difference where Alvarez is is Alvarez
is this line right here no no sorry
that's adley Alvarez is here he's so
much closer to home plate he's bringing
it up into the line of vision much
closer to home plate the more a ball
travels the lower it gets right gravity
and all that good stuff you want to
catch it at its uh before it gets too
low and Flash it up real quick and one
of them gets the strike and the other
does not and they're both similar if
anything the pitch that was called the
ball was higher by you know a tiny bit
and there's a big difference there now
look at where the umpire's head is
because Alvarez is getting
closer Tay's head is much closer look
here's Tay's head for Alvarez right
there here's Tay's mask for adley so
he's getting a completely different look
right he's he's getting to see more
because he's closer and he can see the
bottom a little bit better and he's just
getting closer you get closer you get a
better look at everything right so and
your angles are all
different that's what it
is it's just the catcher just stealing
strikes let's watch another one on the
left here we've got
1.49 ft off the ground on the right 1.5
again again the the pitch to Lindor is
actually higher than the pitch to I
don't know who the batter is for the
Oriols in this one um oh it's Rush it's
it's
adley here's the overlay so if I go slow
on
it by the time they cross you can see
one is a little bit higher than the
other both catchers catch it and one
gets the strike and one gets Ball
Four here it is again now they both
Flash the target at the start very
similar right adley's going to hold his
there or actually okay so adley brings
his down this time but not that
quick yeah not that quick and Alvarez
brings it all the way to the dirt and
then when they come
up adley holds it and the other the new
style is don't hold it and try to like
frame it keep it moving keep it moving
the umps don't like when you do that so
here it is from the side again and again
you can see the difference in where the
catcher's head is where the catcher's
glove is now I talked to a catching
coach in Major League Baseball about
this when contus got hurt and he was
telling me that this is very Advanced
for some teams They Know Each hitter's
tendency how long a hitter swing is to
avoid getting into getting catchers
interference that for some pitches like
breaking pitches on this batter they can
be here and breaking pitches on this
batter they can't be there fast balls
they have a ton of data points and I
went to a Yankees game and I watched uh
the two catchers and you can see that
they're setting up in different places
all the time so some teams are really
really really smart about this to steal
strikes and look at T Payne's head again
they're just it's just so much closer
the glove is so much closer doesn't let
it travel as much the frame job is way
out like the frame
job is so much further this is where
Alvarez's glove
is and this is where adley's glove
is That's
So it's like two feet
closer which helps get that strike
because it never gets that low you catch
it right there you put it up in the zone
you flash it you drop it umpire loves it
look again and look at the heads that's
Tay there that's Tay there these pink
lines I'm putting on screen
so I love this stuff and it was a huge
difference in this game they got Alvarez
got so many
calls so many and adley
got none none low they had a couple left
and right of the Zone man look at lows
my mind how close catchers get now when
you go to a game watch for that watch
for how close the catcher getting he's
like right up on player it's nuts and
the Umpire follow suit it's way closer
so I thought that was interesting I love
that stuff thought I'd share that with
you that was topic number one and if you
enjoy that stuff you might enjoy all the
other stuff I cover on that show every
Tuesday because it's a little more long-
winded a more a little more in depth of
stats and techniques and stuff like that
this breakdown is brought to you by
SeatGeek I want to thank them for
sponsoring the video you can use code
johnboy for $20 off your first purchase
on SE that's $20 off your first purchase
with promo code johnboy make sure you
click the link in the description to
download the app thank you guys see you