Umpire admits he was wrong in the World Series, a breakdown

Jan 15, 2026 169.9K views 8:00

What Happened

Aaron Judge steps into the batter's box in the bottom of the ninth, the New York Yankees trailing by one. The stakes are high as the Yankees look to mount a late-inning comeback in this crucial World Series matchup. Deion Sanders, the speedy outfielder for the Atlanta Braves, steps up to the plate with a .500 batting average in the postseason. The Braves have been dominant on the basepaths, setting a playoff record by going 13-for-13 in stolen bases. The first pitch from Braves pitcher Alejandro Guzman is a called strike. Sanders then fouls off the next pitch, putting himself in an 0-2 hole. Guzman mixes in a breaking ball that misses the zone low, and Sanders wisely holds off. On the next pitch, Sanders hits a slow roller towards first base. Guzman fields the ball cleanly and throws to John Olerud, but the throw pulls Olerud off the bag, allowing the lightning-fast Sanders to reach safely. With Sanders on first, the Braves waste no time trying to put him in scoring position. Olerud makes multiple pickoff attempts, keeping Sanders close. Finally, on the sixth pickoff try, Olerud appears to tag Sanders as he comes off the bag, but the umpire, Bob Davidson, rules Sanders safe, much to the dismay of the Blue Jays' third baseman, Kelly Gruber. "I tagged him right on the foot," Gruber protests, but Davidson stands by his call, saying, "I saw daylight, so I gotta go with what I saw." Gruber is left "dumbfounded" by the umpire's admission that he may have missed the play. The defensive miscue proves costly, as Braves third baseman Terry Pendleton singles to right field, advancing Sanders to second base. Deion Sanders then breaks for third on the hit, and Gruber dives to make the tag, but the umpire again rules Sanders safe, much to Gruber's disbelief. "Oh, come on. What?" Gruber exclaims, convinced he had made the play. After the game, umpire Bob Davidson acknowledges his mistake, saying, "I thought I was 100% right. Then I saw the replays and the pictures, and I thought, 'Ah, I probably missed the play.'" Davidson's admission does little to console the Blue Jays, who missed out on the chance to turn the second triple play in World Series history.

Full Transcript

Click timestamps to jump to that moment

Deion Sanders coming to bat for the Braves in game three of the World Series.

He's got a 500 batting average in the World Series. The Braves are 13 for

13 in stolen bases. Postseason record. I don't know if it's been broken. We're tied

up in game three. First pitch, Joe West says, stride. Next pitch, he

went up and away. Now he goes up and in. He's in an 0-2 hole.