Ump throws out Phillies Pitcher and even the Dodgers argue it, a breakdown

Jul 16, 2019 6.9M views 2:12

What Happened

In a lopsided matchup at Citizens Bank Park, the Los Angeles Dodgers are routing the Philadelphia Phillies 12-1 in the late innings. Dodgers outfielder Alex Verdugo steps up to the plate and swings through a fastball, but then crushes an off-speed pitch for a two-run homer, extending the Dodgers' lead. The very next pitch from the Phillies' pitcher hits Dodgers third baseman Justin Turner in the leg. Immediately, home plate umpire Joe West ejects the Phillies pitcher, to the dismay of the Philadelphia crowd. Turner is stunned, looking around in disbelief as catcher J.T. Realmuto tries to figure out what just happened. Dodgers outfielder Joc Pederson argues that the pitch was a curveball, not an intentional hit-by-pitch. Phillies manager Joe Girardi comes out to discuss the call with West, but West stands by his decision, telling Girardi "he kept coming inside, I can't have a batter get hit." Girardi continues to plead his case, with West responding "I had to throw him out." Girardi makes an exasperated gesture, knowing his team is already down big and can ill-afford losing their starting pitcher. Dodgers manager Dave Roberts also comes out to voice his disagreement with the call, though it's clear the umpire has made up his mind. "There's no f***ing reason" to eject the pitcher, Girardi tells West in frustration. The Dodgers' dugout, meanwhile, is amused by the situation, with players laughing and talking about the umpire's questionable decision. "Are you guys talking about me over there? Are you guys talking about me and laughing about me over there?" West asks the Dodgers, to which they readily admit "Yes, yes we are." The umpire appears to realize he may have overreacted, but stands by his call as the Dodgers continue to enjoy the absurdity of the moment. This heated exchange between the managers, umpire and players showcases the passionate nature of baseball rivalries, as well as the sometimes-contentious relationship between teams and umpires. Despite the lopsided score, the drama of this incident provides an entertaining sideshow for fans and observers alike.

Full Transcript

Click timestamps to jump to that moment

we had a fun situation in Philadelphia

the Dodgers were crushing the Phillies

Verdugo swinging through that fastball

but crushes that off-speed pitch for a

two-run homer make it a 12 to 1 game