Pitcher accused of cheating via his hair, a breakdown

Sep 13, 2022 3.1M views 7:30

What Happened

Guardians reliever James Karinchak got checked for foreign substances during a September 2022 game against the division-rival Twins after his habit of touching the back of his hair before nearly every pitch caught Rocco Baldelli's attention. Umpire Ted Barrett came out, ran his fingers through Karinchak's hair and inspected his hat, and found nothing illegal. Karinchak, cleared and clearly annoyed, kept yanking at his hair between pitches and immediately gave up a two-run homer to Carlos Correa that pulled Minnesota within 7-6.

Why This Matters

This was MLB's first full season enforcing the sticky-stuff crackdown that arrived in June 2021, and Karinchak became a poster child for it. His spin rate cratered when umpires started checking hands, then climbed back, which is exactly the pattern that makes opponents suspicious. The rule lets a manager request a check, and Baldelli used it as much for gamesmanship as belief. The mechanics here matter: sweat mixed with rosin is legal, foreign goo is not, and pulling at long hair is one of the gray-area grip tricks pitchers leaned on after the ban. The check found nothing. The aftermath stung Cleveland anyway, because Correa sat on the curveball and homered in a tight September game between two clubs fighting for the AL Central. The Guardians ultimately won that division.

With 3.1M views, this breakdown ranks 50th of 1,583, putting it in the top 3.2% of everything Jomboy has ever broken down.

Key Moments

Who / What Is Involved

Players: James Karinchak. Teams: Guardians.

Key Terms Mentioned

Full Transcript

Click timestamps to jump to that moment

an umpire pet a man's hair like he was

his pet cat this breakdown is brought to

you by draftkings this is james karen

shack he's on the mound for the

guardians looking in for the signs and a