Pitchers cheating with sticky stuff, a breakdown

May 29, 2021 2.2M views 11:08

What Happened

On May 26, 2021, Cardinals reliever Giovanny Gallegos jogged in from the bullpen with a noticeable shiny spot on his cap. The second base umpire flagged it, and crew chief Joe West asked Gallegos to swap caps rather than make a scene. Gallegos explained it was rosin mixed with the sunscreen on his arm, but West confiscated the hat and locked it in the umpire room as evidence. Cardinals manager Mike Shildt stormed out and ripped the league for nitpicking a kid over sunscreen and rosin while ignoring pitchers using far worse spin-boosting concoctions. Gallegos then struck out the next two hitters anyway.

Why This Matters

This is the moment MLB's sticky-stuff problem moved from podcast chatter to a national story. The key distinction Shildt and others drew was grip versus spin. Hitters never minded rosin or sunscreen helping pitchers control the ball, because a slick ball at 95 is dangerous. What changed was concocted substances like Spider Tack that artificially crank up spin rate, turning a 2500 RPM slider into 3000 for a single nasty pitch. That's the cheating. The video name-checks Trevor Bauer admitting to the gray-area sunscreen-rosin mix back in 2018, plus J.T. Realmuto, Josh Donaldson, and Dallas Braden all calling for a crackdown. Within weeks of this clip, the league did exactly that, announcing in June 2021 that umpires would begin mandatory checks and suspending violators ten games. Gallegos became an early symbol of a rule baseball had ignored for decades.

At 2.2M views this breakdown ranks 93rd of 1,583 Jomboy breakdowns, landing in the top 5.9% of the catalog.

Key Moments

Who / What Is Involved

Players: Aaron Guías, Joe West. Teams: Cardinals.

Key Terms Mentioned

Full Transcript

Click timestamps to jump to that moment

relief pitcher for the cardinals ghost

is running in

to the game you can see he's got a

little shiny spot on his hat there the

umpire saw it