Runner misses home plate & Brewers use loophole to review it, a breakdown

Jul 27, 2021 2.8M views 6:09

What Happened

In a July 2021 game between the Brewers and White Sox, Milwaukee led 4-0 with the bases loaded and nobody out. A White Sox batter put a dribbler in play that bounced toward home, where the runner appeared to score but actually never touched the plate. The home plate umpire called him safe because the ricocheting ball forced his eyes off the runner's feet. Rather than challenge immediately, the Brewers called a mound visit to buy time and study the replay, then had pitcher Corbin Burnes step off and appeal at home plate, getting the runner ruled out. White Sox manager Tony La Russa argued the maneuver violated a rule he helped implement, but New York confirmed it was legal.

Why This Matters

Replay challenges are meant to fix obvious blown calls inside a tight 20-second window, not to give teams a fishing expedition. The Brewers found the gap. By calling a mound visit first, they got extra time to confirm on video that the runner missed the plate, then used an appeal play, which is reviewable separately from the original call. La Russa, who worked with Joe Torre when MLB built the replay system, insisted there was language barring exactly this. There wasn't. The appeal stood and the run came off the board. The aftermath was almost poetic justice: Burnes promptly walked in the same run, then struck out a batter and got a flyout to escape with only one run allowed. Burnes was in the middle of a Cy Young caliber 2021 season for Milwaukee.

At 2.8M views this sits at #62 of 1,583 Jomboy breakdowns, landing in the top 3.9% of the entire catalog.

Key Moments

Who / What Is Involved

Players: Corbin Burnes, Tony La Russa, Tony. Teams: Brewers.

Key Terms Mentioned

Full Transcript

Click timestamps to jump to that moment

there was an interesting replay review

some gamesmanship a discussion in the

brewers versus white sox game last

weekend and i find it interesting so i'm

going to talk about it milwaukee's up