Runner misses home plate & Brewers use loophole to review it, a breakdown
What Happened
In a July 2021 game between the Brewers and White Sox, Milwaukee led 4-0 with the bases loaded and nobody out. A White Sox batter put a dribbler in play that bounced toward home, where the runner appeared to score but actually never touched the plate. The home plate umpire called him safe because the ricocheting ball forced his eyes off the runner's feet. Rather than challenge immediately, the Brewers called a mound visit to buy time and study the replay, then had pitcher Corbin Burnes step off and appeal at home plate, getting the runner ruled out. White Sox manager Tony La Russa argued the maneuver violated a rule he helped implement, but New York confirmed it was legal.
Why This Matters
Replay challenges are meant to fix obvious blown calls inside a tight 20-second window, not to give teams a fishing expedition. The Brewers found the gap. By calling a mound visit first, they got extra time to confirm on video that the runner missed the plate, then used an appeal play, which is reviewable separately from the original call. La Russa, who worked with Joe Torre when MLB built the replay system, insisted there was language barring exactly this. There wasn't. The appeal stood and the run came off the board. The aftermath was almost poetic justice: Burnes promptly walked in the same run, then struck out a batter and got a flyout to escape with only one run allowed. Burnes was in the middle of a Cy Young caliber 2021 season for Milwaukee.
At 2.8M views this sits at #62 of 1,583 Jomboy breakdowns, landing in the top 3.9% of the entire catalog.
Key Moments
Who / What Is Involved
Players: Corbin Burnes, Tony La Russa, Tony. Teams: Brewers.
Key Terms Mentioned
Full Transcript
Click timestamps to jump to that momentthere was an interesting replay review
some gamesmanship a discussion in the
brewers versus white sox game last
weekend and i find it interesting so i'm
going to talk about it milwaukee's up
four to nothing and this one's brought
to you by seat geek you go to seat geek
you use code john boy you get 20
off your first order any sporting event
concert you want to go to anywhere with
seats that you got to pay for you get 20
off so the 3-1 pitch from burns who's
having an amazing season is put in play
but wong can't come up with the ball
so you got to run a run first i mean it
would have been a nice play
it kind of eats them up but you do have
the runner on first the next one is just
a little dribbler down the line we're
gonna pick it up we'll check the runner
all good okay all good so now you got
two on and no one's really gotten a full
hit yet and then another bloop and yelly
can't come up with it and that's still
not
a hard hit ball so you got bases loaded
man on third man on second man on first
no one out in a bit of a jam nice pitch
for strike one
fastball away cutter right down the
middle for strike two goes for the swing
and miss curve swings
barely hits it up the line another
dribbler throw at home
he's safe what happens is the umpire's
supposed to be watching the runner's
foot
but instead the ball starts coming at
him so naturally he's
looking at the ball that's about to hit
him and not the runner's feet
and you can see him kind of just say
safe i'm going to guess he stepped on
home plate because
normally 100 percent of the time they
just step on home plate there
but he didn't actually see him step on
home plate because the ball ricocheted
and hit him
which i'm fine with now they don't
challenge it
right away they have a mound visit which
gives them a lot more time
to look at the replay and they say hey
fix your hair real quick make sure you
look good because we're about to pull
an appeal step off the mound and throw
home and appeal at home
and the umpire says time and he thinks
he wants a new ball no burn says no
we're appealing that he steps he says
well
okay safe and then he looks he's like i
got him at safe
and then council's gonna come out and
he's gonna talk to him and he's gonna
tell him
i think he missed home plate and i think
it's interesting that he says i think
because by this point they watched
the replays they're positive he missed
home plate but they're acting like it's
a guess
which is weird and you're like well i
had him safe and he said well can you
check on it and he goes to the crew
chief he says i think he missed home
plate
now the crew chief says but you had him
hitting it and he says yeah and he said
well we want to check on us
okay let's check on it maybe the home
plate umpire okay let's bring it out
maybe the home plate umpire
knows that hey i wasn't really watching
because the ball was coming at me
so let's check on it or this is a legal
replay
but yeah he definitely missed home plate
and then never touched it and home plate
just
looking lonely right there all by itself
and this guy says safe and he says no
out he says no safe and he says no
out that's out no that's safe so these
guys are debating it pretty hard and
then they say it's out and he says i
told you
out and he's like oh how he says
larry says hey come here real quick
hey you why don't you come here real
quick and council's like
he made a mound visit you can't then
have a replay
after the mountain visit and they say
well no he didn't he had a replay on the
appeal not the play and louise
oh you sneaky what
what uh hold up what confusion
galore counsel says oh are they on to us
and he says hold up time out real quick
i worked in the front office with joe
torre and we put in place
that you could not have use a mound
visit to stall
so real quick what this is interesting
Tony russo worked with joe torre in the
front office when they implemented
replay
and they saw all the ways that it was
getting game because you only have
20 seconds to challenge a play
now they didn't challenge that he missed
home plate
in that 20-second span they sent a guy
to
the mound to do a pitching visit and
that gave them more time to look at the
replay then they appealed
then they challenged the appeal it does
seem like a huge
loophole because the challenge how
baseball wants it to be is it has to be
so
blatantly obvious that you can see that
it's wrong in 20 seconds you can't
just go fishing for stuff wildly so i
don't know
in some parts of my head i feel like
this is legal
and some parts of my head i'm like
that's definitely a loophole you bought
yourself more time
and larussa is telling them he's saying
i thought that we implemented something
that you cannot
challenge a play after the mound visit
you have to do it before the mountain
visit the umpires were like well i don't
know i mean
that seems pretty in the weeds if you
say you work for the front office then
maybe like
we can get together and discuss it so
they get together and discuss it like
anyone know what he's talking about and
he's like this is
let's let's figure this out council's
like what is he complaining
about now and then they come back and
they're like it's fine and he's like no
i i swear there's a rule that says you
can't do that
i'd like you to call new york and ask
them so they get on the phone
with new york and this is just a rule
book check and the fans were like what
the hell is this all about what's going
on
and they get there and then they say hey
Tony yeah no rule
says that's illegal uh that's totally
legal and he's like okay well
uh seems messed up but we'll continue
the inning continues
and burns walks the next batter and
maybe that's the great equalizer in all
of this they get their run
then he's going to throw a nice strike a
nice strike
and a really nice curveball
for the second out of the inning look at
that
break it just dives at the end beautiful
then he's gonna get anderson to fly out
and escapes the inning only gives up one
run that's the only run he'd give up in
the game
good job by them this video was brought
to you by
seat geek go to seat geek go to sporting
events
go there get confused because mlb
doesn't actively tell you what's going
on when there's a replay and they should
but they don't
but you'll have a nice seat and you'll
have twenty dollars off because you use
code jomboy when you bought it